Robinson, who was physically disabled and blind in one eye, was stabbed nine times in the face and neck and found barely alive on his bed. He died while en route to receive treatment.
A jury convicted August in November of 2012 based on circumstantial evidence, including reports that August had recent violent confrontations with Robinson’s grandchildren and was heard to threaten them.
Attorney Anthony Sylvestre, who replaced late original trial attorney Lionel Welch, argued that the circumstantial evidence was insufficient in itself to tie his client to the crime and that Justice Adolph Lucas failed to properly direct the jury on the legal concept of “joint enterprise”, as it was alleged that August and another unknown person killed Robinson.
The Director of Public Prosecutions Cheryl-Lynn Vidal responded for that office. A decision will be given at a later date.